MHRA-LOGO.gif (6825 bytes) Medicines and Healthcare products
Regulatory Agency

Market Towers
1 Nine Elms Lane, London SW8 5NQ


Mr Charles Medawar
Social Audit Ltd
P.O. Box 111
London NW1 8XG

General enquiries
Telephone 020 7273 0000  Fax 020 7273 0353
E-mail [email protected]

Direct line:  020 7084 2534
Direct fax:  020 7084 2548

Email:   [email protected]


10 June 2004 

Dear Mr Medawar,

Thank you for your letters of May 4th and June 8th . I apologise for the delay in replying.

In response to the first and second points in your letter of May 4th, the MHRA does not accept that the statement made on the website was defamatory. The text was a statement of the Agency’s opinion that the criticisms made in your article are not accurate, for the reasons set out in the answer. The Agency’s opinion was based on its knowledge of existing procedures and it was entitled to express the view as it did.

On your third point, I can confirm that the MHRA did not communicate with the International Journal of Risk & Safety in Medicine.

The Agency is preparing a detailed response to the points made in your article. This is taking longer than we anticipated. We would be happy to discuss the results of this analysis with you and Dr Herxheimer once it has been completed.

Yours sincerely

Sir Alasdair Breckenridge